Can R22 and R134a refrigerants be used interchangeably? Refrigerant science knowledge
Publication Time:
2022-11-02 17:12
Source:
1. R134a has a global warming potential (GWP) of 0.25, while R22 has a GWP of 0.36; both are greenhouse gases.
2. R134a has an ozone depletion potential (ODP) of 0, while R22 has an ODP of 0.06. This is why R134a is considered an environmentally friendly refrigerant.
3. R134a has a specific volume 1.47 times that of R22, and lower latent heat of vaporization. Therefore, the refrigeration capacity of R134a units is only 60% that of R22 units. In terms of price per unit of refrigeration, R22 units cost approximately 60% of R134a units.
4. R134a's thermal conductivity is 10% lower than R22's. Therefore, R134a units require heat exchangers with a larger heat transfer area.
5. R134a is highly hygroscopic, 20 times more so than R22. Therefore, higher demands are placed on the system's dryer to prevent ice blockage.
6. R134a has a stronger swelling effect on rubber materials than R22, resulting in a higher refrigerant leakage rate in actual operation. Additionally, it is more corrosive to copper, leading to a "copper plating" phenomenon during use. Therefore, additives must be added to the system.
7. R134a systems require dedicated compressors and specialized lubricating oils. These lubricating oils, due to their high water absorption, high foaming, and high diffusion properties, are inferior in system stability to the mineral oils used in R22 systems.
8. R134a and other HFC refrigerants, along with their specialized lubricating oils, are more expensive than R22, leading to higher equipment operation and maintenance costs.
Other HFC refrigerants, such as R410A, R440A, and R407C, which are known as environmentally friendly refrigerants, although superior to R134a in efficiency, have drawbacks such as excessively high operating pressures, high demands for optimized pipeline components and pressure resistance, the need for improved heat exchanger and unit designs, and high investment, operation, and maintenance costs. These shortcomings make them currently unsuitable for large refrigeration units in China. This is the reason why the international conventions have eased the timeline for phasing out HCFCs in developing countries, a result of collective efforts by developing nations.
Friendly reminder: Counterfeit products are widespread, making it difficult to avoid. When purchasing, don't be tempted by low prices. Always buy from reputable brands to avoid potential damage to the compressor from contact with inferior refrigerants...